HomeHealth articlescolonoscopyWhat Is Cologuard versus Colonoscopy?

Cologuard Versus Colonoscopy - Difference, Preparations, and Risks

Verified dataVerified data
0

4 min read

Share

Colorguard is an accurate test done to diagnose colon cancer but not polyps, whereas colonoscopy can detect both colon cancer and polyps.

Medically reviewed by

Dr. Vasavada Bhavin Bhupendra

Published At December 15, 2022
Reviewed AtJune 28, 2023

Introduction:

Colorguard is a stool test that detects the mutations in the DNA and detects the precancer and cancer from the stool sample. Cologuard is a non-invasive test that can be done at home and sent to the laboratory for analysis. The test should be done every three years.

What Is a Colonoscopy?

A colonoscopy is a gold standard test for diagnosing colon cancer. But it is an invasive test done by a medically qualified professional. The procedure involves inserting a flexible tube with a light and camera attached to it called the colonoscope and introducing it till the end of the colon. Also, if the doctor sees any polyps during colonoscopy, they can remove them at the same time and send them to the lab for further investigation.

What Is the Difference Between Colonoscopy and Cologuard?

  • The main difference between a cologuard and a colonoscopy is that colonoscopy is an invasive procedure, whereas a cologuard is a non-invasive procedure. But the colon cannot be visualized in the cologuard as in a colonoscopy.

  • The cologuard can miss up to 50 % of precancerous polyps and about 8 % of colon cancers.

  • In cologuard, colon cancers are diagnosed and cannot be prevented, whereas colonoscopy can also be prevented.

  • A negative stool DNA test should be repeated every three years, whereas a colonoscopy can be done every ten years.

  • Cologuard (stool DNA test) is not advised for patients with high risk, like patients with a family history of colorectal cancers, irritable bowel disease, and history of polyps.

  • Cologuard does not require any dietary changes whereas, before the colonoscopy, there are certain things to follow as a part of bowel preparation for the procedure.

How to Prepare for a Colonoscopy?

For the colposcopy procedure, the bowel needs to be empty during the procedure. Any residue in the colon can interfere with the images and affect the result. So to empty the colon, the doctor will suggest the following:

  • Follow the Diet - A special diet will be advised by the doctor, who needs to be followed. Any solid food item should be avoided a day before the procedure. Clear liquids may be taken. Also, avoid red-colored drinks, which can be mistaken during the colonoscopy as blood. The night before the procedure, after midnight, no solids or liquids will be allowed.

  • Laxatives - The doctor will advise taking laxatives either in pill form or syrup form, which should be taken at night before the colonoscopy.

  • Adjust the Medications - Inform the doctor about the medications at least a week prior to the procedure, especially medication for hypertension, diabetes, or heart problems. Also, inform the doctor in case one is taking medicines such as Aspirin or other blood thinners like Warfarin which are used to reduce the risk of blood clots or stroke.

What to Expect during Colonoscopy?

During a colonoscopy, the patient is asked to wear a gown, but likely nothing else. Sedation or anesthesia is usually recommended. In most cases, the sedative is combined with pain medication given directly into the bloodstream (intravenously) to lessen any discomfort. The patient will be asked to lie on the exam table to one side, usually with their knees drawn toward the chest. The doctor will insert a colonoscopy into the rectum. The colonoscope is long enough to reach the entire length of the colon and contains a light and a tube (channel) that allows the doctor to pump air, carbon dioxide, or water into the colon. The air or carbon dioxide inflates the colon, which provides a better view of the lining of the colon. When the scope is moved or air is introduced, the patient may feel stomach cramping or the urge to have a bowel movement.

The colonoscope also contains a tiny video camera at its tip. The camera sends images to an external monitor so that the doctor can study the inside of the colon. The doctor can also insert instruments through the channel to take tissue samples (biopsies) or remove polyps or other areas of abnormal tissue. A colonoscopy typically takes about 30 to 60 minutes.

What Are the Risks Associated with Colonoscopy?

A colonoscopy poses few risks. Rarely, complications of a colonoscopy may include:

  • A reaction to the sedative used during the exam.

  • Bleeding from the site where a tissue sample (biopsy) was taken or a polyp or other abnormal tissue was removed.

  • A tear in the colon or rectum wall (perforation).

After discussing the risks of colonoscopy with the patient, the doctor will obtain a signed consent form giving permission for the procedure.

How Is the Cologuard Test Done?

  • The Cologuard testing kit for colon and rectal cancer must be ordered by the healthcare provider. It will be sent by mail to the patient’s address. The patient is asked to collect the sample at home and send it back to the lab for testing.

  • The Cologuard testing kit will contain a sample container, a tube, preserving liquid, labels, and instructions on how to collect the sample. When the patient is ready to have a bowel movement, use the cologuard testing kit to collect the stool sample.

  • Read the instructions that come with the testing kit carefully. The patient is asked to wait until they are ready to have a bowel movement. Collect the sample only when it is possible to ship it within 24 hours. The sample must reach the lab in 72 hours (3 days).

What Are the Risks Associated with Cologuard?

There is no risk involved in taking the sample for the Cologuard test.

Screening tests carry a small risk of:

  • False Positives- The test results are abnormal, but the patient does not have colon cancer or premalignant polyps).

  • False Negatives- The test is normal, even when the patient has colon cancer).

Conclusion:

A colonoscopy is a medical diagnostic procedure that evaluates the large bowel and is performed by a trained physician. The colonoscope is a long, firm, and flexible plastic tube with a small digital camera and light at one end. A colonoscopy can be performed to look for polyps or abnormal growth and as well as to detect early symptoms such as unexplained diarrhea, abdominal pain, or blood in the stool. Early cancers and polyps can both be removed at the same time. Whereas cologuard is performed by the patient at home with the help of cologuard testing kit. No preparation is needed to perform cologuard at home. When compared, both colonoscopy gives accurate results and is the most reliable.

Frequently Asked Questions

1.

Is a Cologuard Test as Effective as a Colonoscopy?

Colon cancer prevention depends on finding and eliminating polyps. However, Cologuard detects large precancerous polyps only 42% of the time, whereas a colonoscopy detects them 95% of the time and removes them at the same time during the procedure. Thus, the cologuard test is less efficient than a colonoscopy.

2.

Why Do Doctors Not Prefer Cologuard?

Cologuard has a greater incidence of false positives (a test indicating the presence of disease when the person doesn’t have the disease) than the fecal immunochemical test (FIT), but it is more effective than FIT at detecting cancer. Cologuard has a 13% false-positive rate, and that rate rises with advancing age. Since Cologuard is less accurate than a colonoscopy at detecting polyps of any size, doctors don’t prefer a cologuard over a colonoscopy.

3.

What Is the Best Screening Test for Colon Cancer?

One of the most accurate procedures for colon cancer detection presently available is a colonoscopy. The intestines and rectum both are visible and examined by the healthcare provider. Through the scope, abnormal tissue, such as tumors, and polyps can be removed, and tissue samples (biopsies) can be taken for further process in diagnostic confirmation.

4.

Does Colon Cancer Require a Colonoscopy to Be Detected?

Three stool test kinds that have been authorized by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for the detection of colon cancer are the fecal immunochemical (or immunohistochemical) test (FIT or iFOBT), guaiac FOBT (gFOBT) and multitarget stool DNA testing, also known as FIT-DNA. Alternative stool tests for colon cancer detection can be used by people who cannot undergo a colonoscopy due to conditions like a recent myocardial attack, bowel injury, or surgery.

5.

Can Colon Cancer Be Detected Without a Colonoscopy?

A stool test can be done to detect colon cancer. A sample of your stool is used in the stool DNA test to search for DNA alterations in cells that could point to the existence of colon cancer or precancerous conditions. Additionally, the stool DNA test examines for indicators of blood in your feces. One should gather a stool sample for this test at home and then submit it to a facility for analysis.

6.

What Are the Cologuard Test’s Potential Risks?

A clinical study found that 8% of patients with cancer got negative results (false negative) and 13% of patients without colorectal cancer or advanced adenomas got positive results (false positive), respectively. Therefore, the results are not always valid with a cologuard test.

7.

Is There an Alternative to Cologuard?

The alternative to the cologuard test is stool tests and a colonoscopy to accurately detect and treat colon cancer and other colon conditions.

8.

Which Is More Effective, a Stool Test or a Colonoscopy?

The colonoscopy is more accurate than the DNA stool test in identifying precancerous polyps. Additional tests might be required if anomalies are discovered in stool tests. Additionally, the tests may report an anomaly even in the absence of one (false-positive). So a colonoscopy is preferable to a stool test.

9.

What Would Be the Best Alternative for a Colonoscopy?

Studies show that in those with contraindications for colonoscopy, the fecal immunochemical test (FIT) test can be used in place of a colonoscopy. Fecal immunochemical testing looks for hidden blood in the stool, which may be an early sign of colon cancer. A tiny sample of feces is placed for testing in a special collection receptacle or on a special card. The test uses an antibody that binds to the hemoglobin blood molecule to detect the presence of any blood.

10.

What Age Is Advised for a Colonoscopy?

The key to preventing and detecting colorectal cancer early is routine screening, which should start at age 45. Adults between the ages of 45 and 75 should be screened for colon cancer, according to the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. The Task Force advises people between the ages of 76 and 85 to discuss screening with their doctor.

11.

Is Cologuard Expensive?

The test's basic price is greater than the prices of other at-home colon cancer screening tests that are advised. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force has also recommended the fecal immunochemical test (FIT) and the fecal occult blood test (FOBT) as additional test choices for at-home colon cancer monitoring.

12.

Has the FDA Approved Cologuard?

In August 2014, the FDA approved Cologuard following a rigorous evaluation procedure known as Pre-Market Approval.

13.

How to Collect Feces for Cologuard?

Open the Cologuard package and verify the expiry date before using it. Put the sample container in the toilet bracket using the Cologuard kit. Fill the sample container with stabilizers after scraping the sample.

14.

Is a Colonoscopy the Ideal Test for Colorectal Cancer?

There is no question that a colonoscopy remains the most reliable test for colorectal cancer detection. The excellent inspection enables physicians to remove precancerous and cancerous polyps while performing the process in addition to detecting colorectal cancers with a 98% success rate.

15.

Is Colon Cancer Curable?

The National Cancer Institute states that colon cancer that is localized to the bowel is highly manageable and frequently curable. The main therapy method is surgery. Most frequently, colon and rectal tumors develop gradually over many years. Most of those tumors develop from a swelling known as a polyp. An early tumor removal could prevent it from developing into malignancy.
Dr. Vasavada Bhavin Bhupendra
Dr. Vasavada Bhavin Bhupendra

Surgical Gastroenterology

Tags:

colonoscopycologuard
Community Banner Mobile
By subscribing, I agree to iCliniq's Terms & Privacy Policy.

Source Article ArrowMost popular articles

Do you have a question on

colonoscopy

Ask a doctor online

*guaranteed answer within 4 hours

Disclaimer: No content published on this website is intended to be a substitute for professional medical diagnosis, advice or treatment by a trained physician. Seek advice from your physician or other qualified healthcare providers with questions you may have regarding your symptoms and medical condition for a complete medical diagnosis. Do not delay or disregard seeking professional medical advice because of something you have read on this website. Read our Editorial Process to know how we create content for health articles and queries.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. iCliniq privacy policy